top of page

When Your Disadvantage is Your Key To Success

3 hours ago
7 min read



By the time I entered the advertising industry, the creative revolution had already transformed it. Its extraordinary impact had reshaped how agencies approached advertising.


And at the foundation of that revolution was Volkswagen's Think Small, the campaign that had turned the industry upside down.


For my generation of copywriters and art directors, it was the benchmark against which creative work was measured. We all dreamed of producing something that would have that kind of impact, something that might change advertising itself. I certainly did.


But above all, the brilliance of Think Small was its extraordinary premise. Doyle Dane Bernbach had been handed an automobile that seemed to possess just about every disadvantage imaginable in the American market. Instead of concealing those disadvantages, the agency found a way to make them desirable.


And what a collection of disadvantages they were.


To appreciate the problem, you have to remember what American automobiles looked like in 1959. They were enormous, glamorous machines with sweeping tail fins, enough chrome to keep a polishing crew employed, and engines powerful enough to satisfy anyone who considered getting from zero to sixty in a hurry one of life's essential pleasures.


The advertising was equally extravagant. Beautiful women, beautiful scenery, and promises of a driving experience bordering on the spiritual. Detroit had become remarkably good at convincing Americans that happiness was waiting for them in the showroom, preferably in the form of something eighteen feet long.


And then there was the Volkswagen.


It was small. It was ugly, or at least sufficiently peculiar-looking to make beauty a difficult argument. Its engine produced about as much excitement as a household appliance. And it was German, which, only fourteen years after World War II, was hardly an advantage in the American market.


I imagine that if you had assembled a committee of automobile executives and asked them to design a car with the least possible appeal to American buyers, they might have come up with something remarkably similar.


Most advertising agencies would have searched for ways to make the Volkswagen appear more like the cars Americans already admired. Perhaps emphasize its engineering, dress it up with attractive photography, and quietly avoid mentioning that it was about half the size of the vehicles competing for attention in American showrooms.


But Bill Bernbach and his creative people recognized something that Detroit seemed to have overlooked.


Not every American was in love with the excesses of the automobile industry. There was a growing audience that found the enormous cars, extravagant styling, and exaggerated advertising increasingly ridiculous. These were people who appreciated practicality, intelligence, honesty, and the occasional opportunity to laugh at conventional wisdom.


And to those people, the Volkswagen's peculiarities might be rather appealing.


Its small size made it economical and easy to park. Its modest engine consumed less gasoline. Its unchanging appearance suggested that the company was more interested in building a useful automobile than in persuading customers to buy a new one every time Detroit discovered another place to attach a piece of chrome.


The agency developed an advertisement showing a tiny Volkswagen surrounded by an enormous amount of white space.


The headline consisted of two words.


Think Small.


It was an extraordinary piece of advertising, not because it made the car look beautiful, but because it made the car's lack of conventional beauty irrelevant.


The agency had found an audience that might actually prefer what everyone else considered disadvantages.


I've always admired the thinking behind that campaign. In advertising, clients generally prefer hearing about their strengths, and advertising people are usually happy to oblige. Suggesting that the things a client regards as embarrassing might be the very things worth celebrating requires a rather different conversation.


I would have enjoyed being in the room when that conversation took place.

But the Volkswagen story has implications that extend well beyond advertising. Some of the most interesting examples come from businesses that didn't have the luxury of choosing which disadvantages they would prefer to live with.


Consider Toyota in the years following World War II.


The company was a relatively small automobile manufacturer operating in a country recovering from enormous destruction. Money was scarce, resources were limited, and the American automobile manufacturers were producing cars in quantities Toyota could scarcely imagine.


The Americans had developed an enormously successful system built around mass production. Large factories produced huge quantities of automobiles, supported by substantial inventories of parts and materials.


Toyota couldn't afford to operate that way.


I imagine there were moments when its executives would have been delighted to possess the financial resources of General Motors. Most business owners have experienced something similar, although perhaps on a slightly more modest scale.


But Toyota's limitations encouraged its engineers to examine the manufacturing process from a different perspective.


Why maintain enormous inventories of parts that might not be needed for weeks? Why produce more than the next stage of manufacturing required? Why accept waste as an unavoidable consequence of doing business?


Over time, Toyota developed a production system that emphasized efficiency, continuous improvement, and producing what was needed when it was needed.


What had begun partly as a response to limited resources became one of the most influential manufacturing systems in the world.


There's something wonderfully ironic about that. Toyota couldn't afford to imitate the wealthy American manufacturers, and its efforts to work around that disadvantage helped produce a system that manufacturers around the world would eventually study and adopt.


I doubt the people at Toyota were sitting around congratulating themselves on their shortage of money. They were trying to build automobiles and stay in business. But necessity has a way of encouraging questions that prosperity sometimes allows us to avoid.


Something similar happened in a small grocery business in Germany.

After World War II, two brothers, Karl and Theo Albrecht, operated a modest grocery operation in a country where money was scarce and customers watched their spending carefully.


They couldn't offer the enormous selection of merchandise that larger supermarkets provided. Their stores were plain, their assortment limited, and the shopping experience was unlikely to inspire anyone to write poetry about it.

Ordinarily, a grocery retailer would regard those limitations as problems to be corrected as soon as the business could afford it.


The Albrecht brothers took a different view.


They recognized that offering fewer products simplified almost everything about running a grocery store. Purchasing became easier. Inventory was reduced. Stores required less space and fewer employees. Goods could be displayed in their shipping cartons rather than arranged in elaborate presentations.


All of which made it possible to offer customers lower prices.


And the customers, many of whom had more pressing concerns than choosing among seventeen varieties of canned peas, were perfectly happy with the arrangement.


The brothers eventually developed their business into Aldi, one of the world's most successful discount grocery chains.


I particularly enjoy the Aldi story because it raises an interesting question about what customers actually want.


Retailers have traditionally assumed that more choice is better. More products, more brands, more varieties, more opportunities for the customer to wander through the store wondering which of twelve nearly identical products to buy.


Aldi demonstrated that many customers were willing to accept less choice in exchange for lower prices and a simpler shopping experience.


The brothers hadn't discovered a clever way to apologize for their limited assortment. They had discovered that the limitation itself could be valuable.


I've thought about these stories in relation to the small business owners I've worked with over the years.


Most began their businesses without everything they would have liked. Not enough money, not enough people, inadequate facilities, limited equipment, or competitors who seemed to possess all the advantages.


And as the business grew, there were always new things to wish for.


That's understandable. When you're responsible for meeting payroll, keeping customers happy, and making certain there's enough money left at the end of the month to do it all again, you don't spend much time celebrating your shortcomings.


You're usually too busy trying to correct them.


But I wonder how often business owners examine those shortcomings closely enough to understand what they might make possible.


A small company may be frustrated by its inability to offer the range of services available from a larger competitor. Yet its narrower focus might allow it to develop a level of expertise the larger company can't match.


A retailer may regard its limited inventory as an embarrassment, without recognizing that some customers would welcome a carefully selected assortment that saves them time and eliminates confusion.


A service business may wish it had more employees, while overlooking the fact that customers appreciate dealing directly with the owner rather than being passed from one department to another.


Of course, not every weakness conceals an opportunity. Sometimes an inadequate piece of equipment is simply an inadequate piece of equipment, and the best thing you can do is replace it before it breaks down on a Friday afternoon.


But there is a difference between recognizing a genuine problem and assuming that everything your competitors possess represents something your business ought to have.

That assumption deserves a little examination.


There are probably quite a few small business owners who could benefit from spending an afternoon looking at their operations with that possibility in mind.


Not with a list of everything they need to improve. They probably already have one of those, and it's likely longer than they'd prefer.


Instead, they might begin with something that has been bothering them for years. Some limitation they've learned to live with, something they've always intended to correct when the business became more successful.


Then examine it from the customer's point of view. Perhaps even ask a few customers what they think.

They may discover that the weakness is every bit as troublesome as they've always believed.


On the other hand, they may discover something they hadn't considered.


After all, in 1959, the people at Doyle Dane Bernbach were handed a small, underpowered, rather ugly German automobile and asked to sell it to a country that seemed to want precisely the opposite.


They didn't ask Volkswagen to build a different car.


They found people who wanted a different kind of car.


I wonder how many business owners are trying to correct something their best customers might actually appreciate.


The Other Side of the Obvious


Some of the most costly business mistakes begin with assumptions nobody thinks to question.


In my free eight-email series, The Other Side of the Obvious, I explore how looking beyond the obvious can reveal opportunities businesses routinely overlook.


Sign up to receive the free eight-email series, delivered every three days.

B

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page